Tuesday, January 14, 2025

Three steps to excape sin.

My post "Is this about sin?" was perhaps too long for a quick read.

Here's the short version

1. Sin is separation from our creator-God and ends in death.

2. Christ, God in human form, defeated death in his resurrection, and evidenced his divinity.

3. He offers us to benefit from this and accept new life in him.

We gain the new life (re-generation, or 'born again') by accepting his offer and following him.

Is this about 'sin'?

Most people, and I'd think some Christians, think of sin as a set of actions.

When we talk about it in public, I think we allow this misapprehension to continue.

Thus the place of 'sin' in the 'economy of salvation' and the whole structure of reality is left untouched both conceptually and explicitly. See Romans 8:19-23.

Sin is not only in our actions, but in our entire disposition towards life, in a corruption of our being as made in God's image: i.e., 'like God' as it is in Genesis 1:27.

Sin results from rejection of God, of repudiation of the fellowship with him we were made for.

So, this is not simple 'moralism' or 'doing the wrong thing'. It is woven into us at a deep level and with that we are cut off from God, the source of life.

Christ: God incarnate in human form, bore the consequence of our rejection in his death, but to not succumb, as we would do. Rather, to defeat it and enable our 'de-separation' from God to come about.

He evidence the defeat of death, the defeat of sin in his resurrection.

From the resurrection flows the offer of new life 'in him'.

This is a complete spiritual re-generation of our inner being, to bring us in to the family of and fellowship with God our Creator.

We are thereby restored to that fundamental life connection and are enabled to be in God's family and know him in Christ, by his indwelling Spirit.

It's not just 'about sin', but by virtue of it, about our separation from God and the path this leads to the natural conclusion of separation: separation devoid of the presence of Christ. Death.

Sunday, January 12, 2025

The Man Who Judged God

I was fascinated by a recent podcast conversation (by Stand to Reason) with 'Dan in Colorado' who wanted to know about God's killing babies.

He was referring to the war against the Midianites in Numbers 31:17-18 and the punishment of Ephraim for apostasy in Hosea 13:16.

I appreciate you didn't have the time available for a lengthy discussion with him, but it got me thinking. How would I respond to his questions?

The first observation I would hazard is that Dan takes an a-historical view of the texts coupled with, perhaps, a deterministic view of God's acts being the source of human/historical acts.

Yet, God's action is in history within its context, as is man's, and the texts report on this. They show God in historical interaction; that is his action is in, through and by history: in a manner, God uses the unfolding of the history of human depravity to achieve his good ends despite the depravity of man which produces a history of degeneracy.

In his 'a-historical' view Dan seems also to have missed the entire point of the OT. It is not merely a collection of narratives, but it lays out the flow of history bringing the Messiah and delineates the historical man in desperate need of the Messiah. It is about the formation and choosing of Israel, itself delivered from slavery, as the base for the Messiah who will deliver us all from slavery to sin and death.

God, rather than being stifled by the reversal in death that man brought upon himself, uses the history marked by it to advance his long game to bring eternal life to all who believe.

Dan seems to take a 'sentimental' view of death. Everyone killed in these judgements, wreaked in the normal course of ANE warfare, itself constrained by the circumstances of the times (more on this below) would have died anyway: as do we all. Death is never 'special' in the history of man. It is condition-normal in our corrupted state and from which we are to be rescued...the great love of God is that he uses the progression of the state of horror we are in to retrieve a people through the coming of the Messiah. He is not finally frustrated by it!

The point of history is not the terminal undoing of mankind in dissolution and death, but in salvation and life. Dan seems to have not considered this.

Dan also seems to bring God wholly into the cosmos with a Euthyphroean option: that 'right' is external to and at least logically, prior to God. Whereas the scriptures teach that all value and ethical judgements flow from God's nature: being that he is love, as John tells us. 'Moral' is what marks our choices because we have the frightening choice: to choose or reject repentance! God, oddly, does not have such a choice: he is who he is, and cannot 'un-be' himself.

Nevertheless, 'love' is also a long game in a world that is full of hate and decay (moral, physical and spiritual) resulting with all this being overturned and put right in the New Creation. God has no 'blood on his hands'.

Moreover the evil done by those who visit it on Ephraim will itself be repaid, as is Moab experiencing, being punished for its rejection of  God and its clear and present danger to the mission of Israel for the rescue of the world. God responds to and uses the evil of Moab and Shalmaneser respectively; he does not cause it, yet is working by it his ultimate Good for those who love him despite the blood-thirsty waywardness of mankind. Working in and by (Romans 8:28) the 'warp and  woof' of human history, because the world is given to man (Ps 115:16) wherein man makes significant choices which must play out, yet will not and cannot frustrate God's ends.

Dan also seems to misunderstand death. I can't remember who stated this, but death is a change of location, not annihilation. Any babies killed would, I think we expect from the scriptures, not be excluded from the love of God, but be saved from the course they would have otherwise gone on. Death in these terms is not the offense of murder.

The practicalities of the ancient world also must be taken into account. They would be twofold: who would look after surviving babies, bearing the financial burden in a very small and fragile economy, to succour the children of the enemy? Moreover, any surviving children would soon enough learn their history and plot to retaliate: who is going to preserve a future guerilla force of angry young men who would be expected to seek their destruction? We see the sentiments of young Arabs in Gaza: perhaps this would be the picture of the adolescent Midian children!

'Evil' is not merely a set of actions that can be abstracted to a particular moral category, but is actions that are 'not-God' or in denial of who God is. This seems to not be fully grasped by Dan. Thus it has no utility apart from sounding the loudest possible alarm that all is not right with the world.  That we detect it (as you say, something is not right with the world), says that we have a transcendental connection to a more basic reality-structure than the world exhibits, by virtue of our imageness of God, I daresay.

The evil in which is the history of the establishment, preservation and preparation of Israel for the Messiah's coming is what life post-fall is, entirely. Dan picks and chooses his 'evils' in some sense. To side-step the evil would be to overturn the fallen world, meaninglessly, as the fallen-ness would continue. Thus, this can only truly be done in the New Creation.

2) God and temporality (the following podcast from the one mentioned above)

I liked the segment in the more recent podcast about God and time. I tend to agree with you, but would fine-tune my own statement of position to recognize that God explicitly  engages with his creation temporally. I've no idea how an a-temporal being would 'work', of course given our experience is of a creation both separate from God, per se, but also congruent with who God is.

Nevertheless, God shows that he is temporally 'synched' with his creation in that he created in the specific cadence of the days that give the tempo to our own experience of the creation. God thus couples with us temporally and substantially in his acts of creation (the ground of fellowship: the parties in the same place and time). He thus sets the context for his other acts within the creation, culminating in the Incarnation.










Tuesday, December 17, 2024

The young Christian

As a young Christian, brought up in a church devoid of any real Christian education, or teaching, I knew nothing.

For many years, while I gradually came to grips with aspects of the Bible as anthology (without knowing that word), it's overall form and 'story' escaped me.

From Sunday School, it struck me as a bunch of disconnected stories and precepts. Not helpful

I came to university knowing nothing of theology, of the history of the church, or the chain of themes that made the Bible the story of reality,  to borrow Greg Koukl's phrase.

One thing conspicuously absent was a table of contents, a meaningful one, of the Bible. A list of Books was only minorly helpful, and only for navigation. A list of the pages of Chapters would have been of some minor use in the early years of Bible reading, but what I needed, I think what everyone needs is a list of contents that are the actual thematic content of the Bible. After all, the navigation aids were as useful for this as discussing a holiday by giving the latitudes and longitudes that one had visited.

The Twentieth Century NT in some editions has such a table of contents, but it is a little too much.

But recently I found in the back pages of my NRSV just the thing. Crossed with the editorial paragraph headings of the NASB, I've adapted these and compiled just what I would have been much helped by (along with teaching of the biblical theology) as a teenager.

I hope it helps you too.

The Old Testament

                                       Book   Topic                                                          Chapter         

The books of the law (Torah) and history: The Pentateuch                                                                

 

GENESIS

The Creation

1, 2

 

 

The Fall

3

 

 

Genealogies

5

 

2350 BC

The Flood

7

 

 

Babel

11

 

2091 BC (call)

Abraham

12

 

2066 BC (b)

Isaac

22

 

2006 BC (b)

Jacob

27

 

1915 BC (b)

Joseph

37

 

EXODUS

Moses out of Egypt

3

 

1446 BC

Israel out of Egypt

12

 

 

Israel at Mt Sinai

19

 

 

The Law

20

 

 

The declaration of creation

31:17

 

 

The exodus continues

33

 

LEVITICUS

Sacrifices

1

 

 

The priesthood ritual

7

 

 

Unclean things and the law

11

 

 

Day of Atonement

16

 

 

A holy congregation

19

 

NUMBERS

The camp at Sinai

2

 

 

Called out of Sinai

10

 

 

A wandering people

21

 

DEUTERONOMY

The Ten Commandments

5

 

 

The Book of the Covenant

12

 

 

God’s chosen people

28

 

 

Blessing from Moses

33

The historical books:

 

JOSHUA

The Promised Land

1

 

1406 BC

Each tribe’s allotment

13

 

JUDGES

Tribal conquests

1

 

1224 BC

Deborah

4

 

1177 BC

Gideon

6:11

 

 

Jephthah

11

 

 

Samson

13

 

RUTH

Ruth and Boaz

1

 

1 SAMUEL

God calls Samuel

3

 

1043 BC

Saul

9

 

1011 BC

David

16

 

2 SAMUEL

David, King of Judah

2

 

 

Absalom’s conspiracy

15

 

1 KINGS

Solomon

2

 

930 BC

A torn kingdom

12

 

 

Elijah

17

 

2 KINGS

Elisha

2

 

 

Samaria conquest

17

 

 

Jerusalem destruction

25

 

1 CHRONICLES

Official lists

1

 

 

The city of David

11

 

 

The ark of the Lord

13

 

 

Temple appointments

23

 

2 CHRONICLES

Building the temple

2

 

 

Solomon’s reign

8

 

 

Kingdom of Judah

11

 

 

Josiah’s reform

34

 

 

Babylonian captivity

36

 

EZRA

Return to Jerusalem

3

 

536 BC

The great assembly

10

 

NEHEMIAH

Ancient walls and gates

2

 

 

The dedication

12:27

 

ESTHER

Haman and Mordecai

4

 

 

 

 

The Poetical Books

 

JOB

Job’s affliction

1

 

 

The questioning

4

 

 

God’s blessing

42

 

PSALMS

Book 1

1-41

 

 

Book 2

42-72

 

 

Book 3

73-89

 

 

Book 4

90-106

 

 

Book 5

107-150

 

PROVERBS

Proverbs of Solomon

1

 

 

Guidance for wise living

22

 

 

Words of Agur

30

 

 

Words of Lemuel

31

 

ECCLESIASTES

Quest for wisdom

9:13

 

SONG OF SOLOMON

The song of songs

1

The Major Prophets

 

ISAIAH

Isaiah and Ahaz

7

 

 

Prophesies about the nations

13

 

 

Isaiah and Hezekiah

37

 

 

Captivity prophesied

39

 

 

Concerning the return

40

 

 

Cyrus

45

 

 

The Lord’s anointed

61

 

JEREMIAH

God calls Jeremiah

1

 

 

The prophet’s persecution

27

 

 

Concerning the nations

46

 

LAMENTATIONS

The fall of Jerusalem

1

 

EZEKIEL

The sins of Jerusalem

4

 

 

God’s judgement

20

 

 

After the fall of Jerusalem

33:21

 

 

The temple of the Holy City

40

 

DANIEL

Nebuchadnezzar’s dream

2

 

607 BC

The golden image

3

 

 

Omen at the feast

5:5

 

 

Daniel’s visions

7

The Minor Prophets

 

HOSEA

Hosea’s experience

1

 

 

God yearns for Israel

11

 

JOEL

The day of the Lord

1

 

AMOS

Judgement of the nations

1

 

 

God and Israel

2:6

 

 

Amos at Bethel

7

 

OBADIAH

The pride of Edom

1

 

JONAH

The prophet’s disobedience

1

 

 

The prophet’s education

2

 

MICAH

Deliver from Bethlehem

5

 

NAHUM

The end of Nineveh

2

 

HABAKKUK

At the watchtower

1

 

ZEPHANIAN

The day of the Lord

1

 

HAGGAI

Rebuilding the temple

1

 

ZECHARIAH

Visions of the night

1

 

 

Visions of prosperity

8

 

MALACHI

A call to remembrance

4

 The New Testament

The Gospels

 

 

 

MATTHEW

The saviour is born

1

 

 

His baptism, temptation

3:13

 

27 AD

In Galilee

4:23

 

 

In Jerusalem

21

 

 

The crucifixion

27:32

 

30 AD

The resurrection

28

 

MARK

Jesus in Galilee

1

 

29 AD

Jesus in Judea

10

 

 

Passion week

11

 

LUKE

Saviour’s birth, youth

2

 

 

His baptism, temptation

3

 

 

His message, mission

5

 

 

Journey to Jerusalem

9:51

 

 

Death and resurrection

23:26

 

 

 

 

 

JOHN

Here is the lamb of God

1:29

 

 

The first Passover

2:13

 

 

The second Passover

6:4

 

 

The third Passover

13

 

 

High priestly prayer,

17

 

 

Passion, Resurrection

18

The Early Church

 

 

 

ACTS OF THE APOSTLES

In Jerusalem

1

 

 

In Judea, Samaria

8

 

 

In Antioch

11:19

 

47 AD

First mission journey

13:4

 

 

Council at Jerusalem

15

 

50 AD

Second mission journey

15:22

 

53 AD

Third mission journey

19

 

 

Paul in Jerusalem

21:17

 

59 AD

Paul goes to Rome

27

Letters of Paul

 

 

 

ROMANS

Message of salvation

1

 

 

The Jews and Gospel

9

 

 

Life in Christ

12

 

1 CORINTHIANS

Dissension in the church

1

 

 

The Lord’s Supper (church gathering)

11

 

 

Gifts of the Spirit

12

 

 

The resurrection

15

 

2 CORINTHIANS

God’s comfort and mercy

1:3

 

 

Ambassadors for Christ

4:16

 

 

Paul’s suffering

11

 

GALATIANS

The gospel of Christ

1:6

 

 

Life in Christ

5

 

EPHESIANS

The household of God

1

 

 

Christian living

4

 

PHILIPPIANS

The mind of Christ

1

 

COLOSSIANS

The supremacy of Christ; creator

1

 

1 THESSALONIANS

His coming is at hand

5

 

2 THESSALONIANS

Prayer and praise

2

Paul’s pastoral letters

 

 

 

1 TIMOTHY

The Christian ministry

1:3

 

2 TIMOTHY

The servant’s duties

2

 

TITUS

Stewards of God

1

Paul’s personal letter

 

 

 

PHILEMON

The runaway slave

1

Other apostolic letters

 

 

HEBREWS

Christ our high priest

4:14

 

 

The better covenant

8

 

 

Heroes of faith

11

 

JAMES

Strength through faith

1:2

 

 

Faith and action

2:14

 

1 PETER

Hope in Christ

1:3

 

 

Stewards of God’s grace

4

 

2 PETER

False prophets

2

 

1 JOHN

Fellowship with the father

1

 

2 JOHN

Love one another

1:4

 

3 JOHN

Co-workers

1

 

JUDE

Resist evil ways

1

Prophesy

 

 

 

REVELATION

Letters to seven churches

1

 

 

Heavenly worship

4

 

 

Opening the seals

6

 

 

Trumpet blasts

8

 

 

The church triumphant

14

 

 

Judgement visions

17

 

 

The New Creation

21

Link to download a PDF of this guide.