Showing posts with label Music. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Music. Show all posts

Sunday, December 3, 2023

Chris Tomlin Wrecks Christian Theology

 Now that's a title to attract clicks!

The lyrics in question are (from Amazing Grace (My Chains Are Gone) ):

The earth shall soon dissolve like snowThe sun forbear to shineBut God, who called me here belowWill be forever mine, will be forever mineYou are forever mine
They aren't Christian!

Well, maybe I'm reading too much into them, but they strike me as having a definite neoplatonic flavour (neoplatonic eschatology is not a Good Thing!).

The earth shall not 'soon dissolve like snow' and the sun forebear to shine.

And the following lines seem to envisage a disembodied 'heaven'.

No, not Christian.

God promises a New Heaven and a New Earth! We will be embodied with 'spiritual bodies'.

Revelation 21.

The story of the Bible is the re-creation of the world where we his people are finally conformed to his image and Christ's triumph over sin is consummated.
 
The New Jerusalem comes down from heaven to earth as the great marker of renewal!

We will be forever his!

Perhaps we should sing;
The earth shall soon dissolve like snow
as God makes all anew
and we shall live before his face
and always know his joy
and always know his joy.

Sunday, May 9, 2021

The good was good, but the bad was...bad

Back to the government imposed over-reaction to a virus with a CFR of .011!

No congregational singing at church. Not even a group of formal singers, but only one person singing.

The precentor read a psalm.

I didn't see anything in the public health order to prevent the congregation reciting the psalm. But we didn't!

Prayer was good, mostly.

I quite liked that the new archbishop was referred to biblically as a 'new overseer'. Excellent that we avoided the very worldly ambiguity of 'leader'.

Unfortunately in the prayer the government authorities in India were referred to as 'leaders' of India, as though they were kings. No, they are 'the authorities'.

Then we had a 'God make everyone better' prayer, as though the Christian faith is a 'protect us from suffering' club.

The prayer should have been: that Indian Christians, missionaries, etc will have opportunities to witness to their faith in many ways, that they will preach the gospel at every opportunity with boldness, and that desperate people might be caused to turn to our Creator in repentance.

We could then go on to ask that we have opportunities to bring the gospel to our nearby Sikh worshipers and introduce them to Christ, and that this might echo through their friends and relatives in India.

Monday, January 11, 2021

Church, but not as you know it.

With the Covid-19 scare prevailing, we have church differently from normal...the normal of two millennia of history!

No singing. The band is a performance unit, rather than a ministry unit. One Bible-reading, one prayer, one sermon.

So, how could we do it to keep the congregation (the church) involved?

Return to responsive readings. A responsive psalm, and the ol' evensong responses brought up to date.

We could speak the words to songs, rather than 'sing', I understand singing is not allowed. I wonder at the epidemiology behind this, but there you are. Church organisers buckled like a wax doll in a spotlight.

We could chant. Chanting is not singing, surely? Or we could hum the songs, maybe sing sotto voce.

And what about a formal choir? It could comprise whoever was 'on' on the day: signified by whoever turned up. Spaced groups of about 5 at five mutually distant points around the auditorium and 25 people singing. Then change choirs for the next song or hymn (and please, no more Bethel or Hillsong efforts). Just remember, singing is instructed by the Apostles. It is not a 'nice to have'; it is an inherent part of our Christian life.

A few people could do prayers: an intro, the main one, and a dismissal prayer or benediction. Or we could do the litany to involve everyone. This might introduce some dignity into the end of the service rather than the trite 'that's all folks' we too often get...for the meeting of the people of God with his Spirit present? Yeek!

And the band. Always good, but 'leaders'?

We were told the band would 'lead us in song'.

No! Bands, choirs, precentors, organists...do not 'lead us'. They minister or serve we the congregation, or any 'doing' words other than 'lead' would work. May be 'let's now sing' or 'let's listen to the band sing for us', etc. But please, they are not a 'leader' or an entertainment troupe, for that matter; although high quality is to be striven for.

Let's get the idea of 'service' back into church life and expunge the worldly idea of 'leadership' with its overtones of superiority, prestige and power, fetching unfortunate images of generals in the military, CEOs in business and party leaders in politics, all with reference to power and influence and preening in the spotlight (the same spotlight that melt's wax dolls, presumably).


Wednesday, December 23, 2020

Superb carols from 2020

 Jussi Bjorling: O Holy Night

And another, by another

And my perennial favourite: particularly sung at the beginning of a Christmas service as the ministers and choir enter in procession. Very moving.

Once in Royal David's City


 

Sunday, August 23, 2020

Drums

Drums in church music are tricky.

How to use rock/jazz drums for hymns?

Here's a suggestion: using the snare to keep a beat aint' good. Its sharp rattly 'crack' doesn't fit the mood of most hymns. Unless its played as it should be, in runs.

Better the toms, and the bassier the better. For instance. (Awesome Wonder, kid's choir)

And how the snare really does its work,  also with great use of the toms. (A closer walk with thee - Wynton Marsalis)

But if you really want liturgical drumming! This is it! (African Sanctus: Gloria)

And so is this. (African Sanctus: Lord's Prayer)


Friday, June 5, 2020

Feast of Bach

Music.

We've been treated by ABC Classic to evenings of Bach sacred cantatas.

This evening (Friday)

Magnificat for 5 voices, 5-part chorus, orchestra & continuo in D major, BWV 243 [27'23]
Cantata, BWV 174 "Ich liebe den Höchsten von ganzem Gemüte" [20'50]
Mass in B minor
Thursday
Cantata, BWV 175, "Er rufet seinen Schafen mit Namen" [15'50]
Wednesday
Cantata, BWV 68 "Also hat Gott die welt geliebt" [13'47]
Tuesday
Cantata, BWV 184, 'Erwünschtes Freudenlight' [21'56]
Monday
Cantata, BWV 173 "Erhöhtes Fleisch und Blut" [13'03]
Friday
Cantata, BWV 59, "Wer mich liebet, der wird mein Wort halten" [11'45]
And so it goes...for ages!
Brilliant.
 
 
 
 
 
 
 

Saturday, April 18, 2020

To round out Easter

After a wonderful string of Easter devotions by Roger Chilton at St Swithun's, I spend this afternoon listening to Bach's St Matthew's Passion by Klemperer. Bliss.

St Matthew

Wednesday, December 4, 2019

Advent 1, more!

I ended my 1st Sunday in Advent listening to Advent music, care of For the God who Sings on ABC Classic FM.

I cannot think of a better way to end the day.

We were treated to:

  • Parry, (Charles) Hubert

    I Was Glad [07'11]
    Choir of King's College Cambridge, Stephen Cleobury (conductor)
    Evensong Live 2019: Anthems and Canticles, King's College KGS0038
  • 10:08pm

    Bach, Johann Sebastian

    Cantata No. 62 "Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland" [19'38]
    Monteverdi Choir, English Baroque Soloists, Joanne Lunn (soprano), Jan Kobow (tenor), Dietrich Henschel (bass), William Towers (alto), John Eliot Gardiner (conductor)
    Bach Cantatas, Vol. 13: BWV 36, 61, 62, 70, 132 & 147, Soli Deo Gloria SDG 162
  • 10:27pm

    Bach, Johann Christoph

    Lieber Herr Gott [04'16]
    Vox Luminis, Lionel Meunier (conductor)
    Johann Bach, Johann Christoph Bach, Johann Michael Bach: Motetten, Ricercar RIC 347
  • 10:32pm

    Schütz, Heinrich

    O lieber Herre Gott, wecke uns auf [03'41]
    La Chapelle Royale, Philippe Herreweghe (conductor)
    Schütz: Musikalische Exequien etc, harmonia mundi HMC 901261
  • 10:35pm

    Milner, Anthony

    Out of Your Sleep Arise [02'43]
    Joseph Wicks (organ), St John's College Choir Cambridge, Andrew Nethsingha (conductor)
    Christmas with St John's, Signum Classics SIGCD 458
  • 10:40pm

    Cooman, Carson

    The Appleton Motets in Op. 767: IV. Watch Therefore [01'59]
    Cambridge Consonance, Jeffrey Grossman (conductor)
    The Welcome News, Gothic G-49280
  • 10:42pm

    Long, James

    Vigilate [04'11]
    St John's College Choir Cambridge, Andrew Nethsingha (conductor)
    Advent Live, Signum Classics SIGCD535
  • 10:46pm

    Byrd, William

    Vigilate [04'42]
    The Cardinall’s Musick, Andrew Carwood (conductor)
    The Byrd Edition, Vol. 8: Cantiones Sacrae; Propers for the Feast of the Purification, ASV CD GAU 309
  • 10:50pm

    Bach, Johann Sebastian

    Cantata No. 61 "Nun komm, der Heiden Heiland" [15'13]
    Monteverdi Choir, English Baroque Soloists, Joanne Lunn (soprano), Jan Kobow (tenor), Dietrich Henschel (bass), William Towers (alto), John Eliot Gardiner (conductor)
    Bach Cantatas, Vol. 13: BWV 36, 61, 62, 70, 132 & 147, Soli Deo Gloria SDG 162
  • 11:06pm

    Jackson, Gabriel

    Vox clara ecce intonate [04'44]
    Truro Cathedral Choir, Luke Bond (organ), Joel Garthwaite (saxophone), Christopher Gray (conductor)
    Vox Clara: Music by Gabriel Jacks, Regent REGCD479
  • 11:10pm

    Jackson, Gabriel

    7 Advent Antiphons [18'05]
    Truro Cathedral Choir, Luke Bond (organ), Joel Garthwaite (saxophone), Christopher Gray (conductor)
    Vox Clara: Music by Gabriel Jacks, Regent REGCD479
  • 11:29pm

    MacMillan, James

    Strathclyde Motets "Dominus dabit benignitatem" [04'34]
    The Sixteen, Harry Christophers (conductor)
    James MacMillan: Miserere, Coro COR 16096
  • 11:33pm

    Gregorian Chant

    Laetatus sum, gradual in mode 7 (Liber Usualis No. 560, GR 139) [02'05]
    Choir and Monks of Farnborough Abbey
    Gregorian Chant, Herald Records 122
  • 11:35pm

    Jachet de Mantua/Adriaen Willaert

    Laetatus sum (Psalm 122) "I sacri e santi salmi..." [06'51]
    Capilla Flamenca, Dirk Snellings (conductor)
    Adriaen Willaert: Vespro della Beata Vergine, Ricercar RIC 325
  • 11:42pm

    De Wert, Giaches

    Il Secondo libro de motetti: Hor est iam nos [08'31]
    Collegium Regale, Stephen Cleobury (conductor)
    Giaches de Wert: Vox in Rama - Il Secondo libro de motetti, Signum Classics SIGCD131 
    This last was in tribute to the recent death of Stephen Cleobury.

Thursday, May 23, 2019

Abide with me

Great comment on the hymn:

How blessed I am to hear this hymn..as many times..I am so blessed and thankful to know that Our Father is always there to listen and to help me and all who believe that He will always Abide with you and me..with the power of the Holy Spirit. Amen

(Wayne Catel)

Thursday, May 16, 2019

Hymns for Vale

Last year I felt near death: after surgery to remove a tumour I had 6 months of chemotherapy. The surgery was successful, but there was a small risk of a metastatic route being present. Thus the precautionary chemotherapy. From mid-way through the course I felt so sick I felt at death's door.

My mind kept turning to my funeral.

Here are the hymns and readings for it:

Tell out my Soul


Tell out, my soul, the greatness of the Lord!
Unnumbered blessings give my spirit voice;
tender to me the promise of his word;
in God my Savior shall my heart rejoice.

Tell out, my soul, the greatness of his Name!
Make known his might, the deeds his arm has done;
his mercy sure, from age to age to same;
his holy Name--the Lord, the Mighty One.

Tell out, my soul, the greatness of his might!
Powers and dominions lay their glory by.
Proud hearts and stubborn wills are put to flight,
the hungry fed, the humble lifted high.

Tell out, my soul, the glories of his word!
Firm is his promise, and his mercy sure.
Tell out, my soul, the greatness of the Lord
to children's children and for evermore!

Thine be the Glory


Thine be the Glory, Risen Conquering Son
Thine be the glory, risen, conquering Son;
endless is the victory, thou o'er death hast won;
angels in bright raiment rolled the stone away,
kept the folded grave clothes where thy body lay.
Refrain:
Thine be the glory, risen conquering Son,
Endless is the vict'ry, thou o'er death hast won.


Lo! Jesus meets us, risen from the tomb;
Lovingly he greets us, scatters fear and gloom;
let the Church with gladness, hymns of triumph sing;
for her Lord now liveth, death hath lost its sting.
Refrain:
Thine be the glory, risen conquering Son,
Endless is the vict'ry, thou o'er death hast won.


No more we doubt thee, glorious Prince of life;
life is naught without thee; aid us in our strife;
make us more than conquerors, through thy deathless love:
bring us safe through Jordan to thy home above.
Refrain:
Thine be the glory, risen conquering Son,
Endless is the vict'ry, thou o'er death hast won.


Handel's I know that my redeemer liveth from Messiah

(play the recording: good audio gear too, no cheap rubbish, even if it costs a few hundred to hire)
(My mother enjoyed singing this aria)

I know that my redeemer liveth
And that he shall stand
At the latter day, upon the earth
I know that my redeemer liveth
And that he shall stand
At the latter day, upon the earth
Upon the earth
I know that my redeemer liveth
And he shall stand
Stand at the latter day, upon the earth
Upon the earth
And though worms destroy this body
Yet in my flesh shall I see God
Yet in my flesh shall I see God
I know that my redeemer liveth
And though worms destroy this body
Yet in my flesh shall I see God
Yet in my flesh shall I see God
Shall I see God

How Great Thou Art

[we all know this one]
(off his African Sanctus album: must be played loudly!) 
(same request as above regarding good audio)

And Bible readings:

Opening of service:  John 1:1-3; Psalm 91:1-2

Philippians 3:7-12

Colossians 1:13-20

Psalm 16:7-11

End of service: Ps 13:5-6

Then Fanshawe's African Sanctus
(also played loudly as a postlude)

At the wake


Dvorak's New World Symphony (we played part at  my father's funeral)
Bach's Cello suites (Julia and I heard these at one of our first outings together).

 

Sunday, March 31, 2019

It's all about me

As far as some contemporary songs go, that is.

Here are the lyrics to a Hillsong piece inflicted on us at church last week:


Who am I that the highest King
Would welcome me?
I was lost but He brought me in
Oh His love for me
Oh His love for me
The whole think is like this and it steps over the line if grace, ambiguously, to my mind, suggesting our worth in the soteriological transaction! The music didn't help, being as soppy as wet bread.

The lyrics are self-indulgent, theological thin and solipsistic: but the church is a people, we are toghether. I'd have been much happier with 

Who are we that the highest King
Would welcome us?
We were lost but He brought us in
Oh His love for us
Oh His love for us

But no chance today.

Compare:
When peace like a river, attendeth my way,
When sorrows like sea billows roll
Whatever my lot, thou hast taught me to say
It is well, it is well, with my soul
It is well
With my soul
It is well, it is well with my soul
Though Satan should buffet, though trials should come,
Let this blest assurance control,
That Christ has regarded my helpless estate,
And hath shed His own blood for my soul

Sunday, August 12, 2018

A cracker!

Today church was a cracker!

We met in the smaller auditorium, while another congregation met in the larger auditorium for 7 (yes, 7!) baptisms.

S. gave a sermon on Colossians 3:8, illustrated amusingly by wearing a pair of ragged old jeans: the practicalities of our faith opened up.

And, two great hymns: How Great thou Art, and 10,000 Reasons. Not just great, but amoung my favourites. The former takes me back to a happy Christian childhood surrounded by Christian family (cousins, aunt and uncle, parents, brother and grandparents), and at the same time prospectively to being in the presence of our Lord for all eternity.

This led me to browsing hymns on YouTube, so I leave you with this selection:

10,000 Reasons

How Great Thou Art

In  Christ Alone

and from Fountainview Academy (and, no, I'm not SDA)

To God be the Glory

Gloria in Excelsis Deo

Crown Him with Many Crowns

and, lastly

How Great Thou Art






Friday, March 9, 2018

Beauty

In the small group I am part of we are working through Simply Christian by N. T. Wright. We watch a video by Wright, which he cutely calls a 'lesson', then we discuss using the workbook we've been given.

Last week's was on relationships and beauty as echos of our creator.

We enthusiastically discussed relationships. Enthusiasm slowed at 'beauty'.

Sure, we all got on board 'natural' beauty. I asked about beauty in our church services. I could see the question marks floating over everyone's head.

No idea!

Some traditions recognise and enjoy beauty in worship as we enjoy the best of human creativity as we collectively turn our attention to our lord. Others, it appears, do not.

Sunday, October 22, 2017

Let's be exuberant

Today, sermon on praise; Psalm 145 to be precise.

We were told a few good things. One that sticks in my mind is that praise is exuberance of delight in God.

So, I reflected on my experience of other church types, bearing in mind our church's disdain for 'performance' or anything like it. Thus we decend to the insulting depths of ill-considered folksiness.

Formal liturgy with everything being done as well as is practical, rehearsed, effort applied, thought through...is a means of exuberant praise.

Preparing for a service without distractions (crying kids, expressive congregations, happiness AOK, of course), acting like adults in the planning and order goes to an exuberant service with the result that all feel good.

And lastly, my eyes wondered to the offensive unadorned back of the upright piano...a slab of small Bosendorfer (such as a model 200, for instance) would be truly exuberant compared to the banal, which is very much unexuberant.

Sunday, September 24, 2017

That's all folks

That wasn't today's benediction at church, but it was darn close.

The conductor (also snr. pastor) introduced the sermon-speaker, then excused himself and left to attend the other service underway in our complex.

No problem with that.

The sermon ended in prayer, the precentors got up to sing, all fine. The song ended, and pause...pregnant pause...more pause.

The sermon-speaker then took the initiative, clearly had not be forewarned, and closed the service, but not knowing how.

A prayer (the only other prayer in the service had been pre and post sermon), and...an awkward, 'that's all folks' type of ending.

Now, my church is averse to being accused of 'mere performance', but this was awkward, if not clumsy.

We don't need the superb polish of St James King Street, but we do need dignity, presence, and good organisation, so that all things are done properly and in good order.

Whatever else happens, a neat, biblical benediction itself can be encouraging, uplifting and hope-building.

Wednesday, September 13, 2017

The music: not performance, but godly

It is easy to confuse good music well done with mere performance; but as we are called to do things well, and this would apply to our music, we must consider that too.

I recently attended with a friend a small ethnic church about 40 minutes drive from my place.

I couldn't understand the language, and wondered what it would be like.

At service start time I became aware of a musical hum. Not acoustic feedback, but on purpose. It grew louder, and varied subtly.

I then noticed the keyboard artist at the synthesiser. I noticed another set of keyboards near him.

The musicians started moving onto the stage: calmly and unassumingly. I knew this was not 'performance' but something done well and in good order.

We ended up with four guitarists, one drummer, two keyboards, four singers. The 'lead' singer (the cantor?) changed, so there was no celebrity occuring. It was Christians joining together in doing a Colossians 3:16. Beautiful. Full of earnestness, but no over-emotive 'swoon' music.

Oddly, I had a similar experience at Christ Church St Lawrence at Easter  many years ago when Austin Day was serving as rector and the choir of King's College at Cambridge was serving as choir.

Saturday, March 18, 2017

Silly songs

Last Sunday was silly song day.

In fact, most Sundays are silly song day.

The lyrics that stuck with me were the repetitive "because of who he is" about God's love; repeated about 5 times, then the response: our 'love': "because of who I am"; also repeated about 5 times.

Sounded like it was pumped out of the Brill Building for a fee, not from the heart of someone who has a story to commit to song...and I don't mean the vacuous story of a 16 year old in their first 'love'. I mean something like Horatio Spafford's "It is well with my soul"

It was so empty that I don't think it was about God's love at all, and the response was completely wrong. Nothing God does is about 'who I am', except one in need of rescue. But Yeshua put aside his divinity "for the joy set before him" and not because of any good time that we would have.

Sunday, February 19, 2017

capital Letters

For some reason the projected songs we sing at church are very oddly capitalised. I wonder if others have detected this. The second person pronoun is often capitalised in respect of God, but not always (particularly if it is 'thee'). Sometimes a common noun is capitalised if not the first in the line, but sometimes not.

It looks drippy. It looks uneducated.